Have you been compromised? Call our active incident line at 1-650-300-7557 or see how we help.

,

Working with your cyber insurer after an attack: who to call, what to document and who does what

If you have cyber insurance and suspect an attack, call your insurer’s claims or breach hotline as early as you can, ideally before you hire outside firms or commit to costs. Many policies set notice requirements, and some require approved (panel) response firms or the carrier’s consent before costs are incurred. The insurer will usually connect you with breach counsel, often called a breach coach, who coordinates the legal side of the response.

You can often keep your own incident response firm involved, but whether its work is covered is the insurer’s decision under your policy, so ask on the first call. ACS Cyber is the managed security services provider (MSSP) and cybersecurity division of Atlantic Computer Systems, with an in-house 24/7 SOC. We work alongside insurer-assigned response firms where your policy permits, and we coordinate with your insurer and counsel when you authorize it.

This guide explains who does what, what to ask and what to document. It is general information, not legal advice or a coverage opinion: your policy wording, your broker and your counsel decide the specifics.

Dealing with an attack right now? Call your insurer’s hotline and our 24/7 incident line at 1-650-300-7557. You do not need to be a client. Active Incident Support lists the first steps to take while you wait for call-backs.

Key terms

  • Breach hotline: the number your insurer gives you for reporting an incident. The FTC’s guidance on cyber insurance for small businesses suggests looking for a policy with a breach hotline available every day of the year at all times.
  • Notice: formally telling the insurer about an incident, in the way your policy specifies.
  • Breach coach: a lawyer, usually experienced in privacy and data security, who coordinates the response and advises on legal and notification obligations.
  • Panel vendors: response, forensic, legal, notification and similar firms the insurer has approved in advance.
  • Consent: the insurer’s agreement, often required in writing, before you hire vendors, incur costs or consider a ransom payment.

When should you notify your cyber insurer after a breach?

As soon as you reasonably suspect an incident, not once every detail is confirmed. Notice clauses differ, and many cyber policies are written on a claims-made basis, so timing can matter. Call the hotline, follow up with written notice if the policy requires it, and record the date, time, claim number and the names of the people you spoke to. Telling your broker helps, but it is not always the same as notifying the insurer.

CISA’s ransomware response guidance lists your cyber insurance company among the stakeholders to engage and keep informed. The same applies to Business Email Compromise and data exposure. Our pages on ransomware response and recovery and data breach response cover the first steps for each.

Who does what after an attack?

Agreeing on roles early prevents duplicated work and costs the policy may not cover. NIST’s incident response guidance, SP 800-61, notes that third parties such as an MSSP may perform response activities under contract, and that their responsibilities should be clearly defined.

PartyTypical role
Your leadershipBusiness decisions, approvals, spending and communications
Your cyber insurerThe claims process, its coverage position, panel firms and consent
Breach counsel (breach coach)Legal advice, including on notification; coordinates the response and may engage the forensic firm
Insurer-assigned response firmForensic investigation and response, scoped with counsel and the insurer
Your security partner, such as ACS CyberContainment, investigation support, recovery and hardening, alongside the assigned firm where the policy permits
Your IT team or IT providerSystem access, knowledge of the environment and restoration work
Your brokerExplains the policy and helps with notice and claim questions

Do you have to use your insurer’s panel firms?

It depends on the policy. Common patterns include:

  • Panel required: response costs are covered only when you use approved firms. You can still involve your own provider, but its costs may not be covered.
  • Others with approval: a firm outside the panel may be used if the insurer agrees in advance, sometimes with conditions on scope or rates.
  • Your choice, within limits: you choose your firms, subject to consent and the policy’s limits.

If you want your own provider involved, say so on the first call and explain why: it already knows your environment and may hold monitoring records that help the investigation. Get any approval in writing. Even when another firm is assigned, your provider can often still help with containment, recovery and the IT work that follows.

This is best settled before an incident. Ask your broker whether your carrier would approve your current security provider for incident work, and keep the answer with your incident response plan.

Why does breach counsel lead the response?

Counsel advises on notification obligations under state breach-notification laws, your contracts and sector rules such as the HIPAA Breach Notification Rule, and shapes communications with customers, regulators and the public. Counsel often engages the forensic firm directly, so the investigation is scoped and reported at counsel’s direction. Whether that affects legal privilege is a question for counsel.

The FTC’s Data Breach Response: A Guide for Business recommends talking to legal counsel and considering outside counsel with privacy and data security expertise, and CISA’s Incident Response Plan Basics notes that attorneys often have preferences on how to engage outside incident response vendors. If the insurer assigns the breach coach, ask whom they represent and how they will work with your own counsel. For law firms, ABA Formal Opinion 483 addresses lawyers’ obligations after a data breach; see our page on cybersecurity for law firms.

How to file a cyber insurance claim after a ransomware attack

These steps apply to most incidents, including Business Email Compromise and data theft. If your insurer, counsel or response team directs otherwise, follow their direction.

  1. Call the claims or breach hotline with your policy number ready, and record the claim number, the time and the names of the people you speak to.
  2. Send written notice if the policy requires it, to the address or portal it names, and keep a copy.
  3. Confirm what needs consent: which vendors, costs and decisions need the insurer’s agreement first. Get approvals in writing.
  4. Bring in breach counsel and agree who engages the forensic firm and how findings will be reported.
  5. Contain without destroying evidence. Disconnect affected systems rather than wiping them, and do not wait for a call-back if the attack is spreading. CISA’s guidance recommends preserving volatile evidence such as memory and logs and imaging a sample of affected devices. In Microsoft 365, default audit log retention depends on your licensing, so preserve those records early.
  6. Report to law enforcement as counsel advises, through the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) or CISA.
  7. Make no ransom decision alone. It belongs to your leadership, with counsel, the insurer and law enforcement involved, and many policies require the insurer’s consent. The Treasury Department’s OFAC advisory on the sanctions risks of facilitating ransomware payments names cyber insurers and incident response firms among the companies that should be aware of those risks, and states that the U.S. government strongly discourages paying ransom demands.
  8. Track every cost: engagement letters, invoices, staff overtime and emergency purchases, each with the approval that covers it.
  9. Record the business interruption: when operations were affected and restored, what work could not be done and any extra expenses.

What should you document for a cyber insurance claim?

Start a written log as soon as you notice something, on paper or on a device you know is clean, and keep the claim file outside the affected systems.

RecordWhy it matters
Incident timelineWhat happened and every action taken, with times and names
Notice, claim number and contactsWhen the insurer was told and who you dealt with
Consents and approvalsShows that vendors, costs and decisions were agreed under the policy
Engagement letters, invoices and staff timeSupports reimbursement of response and recovery costs
Business interruption recordsWhen operations were affected and restored, and what was lost
Preserved evidence and chain of custodyLets the findings hold up for the insurer, counsel and regulators
Attacker messages, kept as foundNeeded by counsel, the insurer and law enforcement

Our page on incident investigation and forensics explains how findings are documented for counsel and insurers.

What should you ask your insurer on the first call?

  1. Does this call count as notice, or is written notice also needed?
  2. Will you assign breach counsel, and can our own counsel be involved?
  3. Must we use your panel firms, and can our current security provider work on the incident?
  4. Which costs need your consent before we commit to them?
  5. What retention and sublimits apply, for example to ransomware or business interruption?
  6. What is the process if a ransom or extortion demand is involved?

How ACS Cyber works alongside your insurer

Our 24/7 incident line is open to organizations that are not clients, so you can call us while you notify your insurer. With your authorization, we coordinate with your insurer and counsel and share facts as they are established.

  • Alongside the assigned firm: we work alongside insurer-assigned response firms where your policy permits, for example on containment, recovery and the IT work that follows, with roles agreed so work is not duplicated.
  • At counsel’s direction: when your counsel engages us, counsel decides how the investigation is scoped, documented and reported.
  • In-house forensic investigation: documented evidence handling and chain of custody, so your insurer and counsel work from a clear record. See our incident response and DFIR services.
  • Pre-approved containment: for clients of our managed detection and response service, SOC analysts take containment actions under rules agreed in advance.
  • Remediation and clean rebuilds: Atlantic Computer Systems, our parent company, provides managed IT and can carry out remediation and clean rebuilds, supported by its managed cloud and backup services.

We do not sell insurance, decide coverage or give legal advice, and whether our work is covered is your insurer’s decision. Our page on post-incident recovery and protection explains how we help you restore operations and prevent a repeat.

What happens at renewal after a claim?

Your carrier may ask what has changed, often about MFA, endpoint detection and response, monitoring, backups and incident response planning. Fix the root causes the investigation found, keep dated evidence of each change and answer accurately. Our guide to the controls cyber-insurance underwriters ask about covers what to prepare, and Atlantic Computer Systems, our parent company, summarizes common cyber insurance requirements.

Keep the insurer’s hotline, your policy number and counsel’s details printed with your incident response plan, because CISA notes that email and document storage may be unavailable during an incident. A tabletop exercise through our cybersecurity advisory and vCISO services lets your leadership rehearse the insurer call before it is needed.

Frequently asked questions

Which incident response firm will work with my cyber insurance?

Any firm your insurer approves for your claim: a firm on its panel or, with the insurer’s consent, one you already use. Ask the claims hotline which firms are approved and whether your own provider can be added. ACS Cyber works alongside insurer-assigned response firms where your policy permits, and our 24/7 incident line at 1-650-300-7557 is open to organizations that are not clients.

Can I use my own incident response firm if I have cyber insurance?

Often, but it depends on your policy. Some policies cover only panel firms, some allow other firms with the insurer’s prior approval, and some leave the choice to you within limits. Ask on the first call, get any approval in writing and, ideally, confirm the position with your broker before an incident.

What is a breach coach in cyber insurance?

A breach coach is a lawyer, usually experienced in privacy and data security, who guides you through the legal side of a cyber incident: coordinating response firms, advising on notification obligations and shaping communications. Insurers often assign or recommend one, so ask whom they represent and how they will work with your own counsel.

When should I notify my cyber insurer after a breach?

As soon as you reasonably suspect an incident, following the notice clause in your policy. Do not wait for the investigation to finish, because facts can be shared as they are established. Record the date, the time and the claim number.

Will my insurer cover costs if we hired a firm before calling them?

It depends on the policy and the circumstances. Some policies do not cover costs incurred without the insurer’s consent, while some make allowances for urgent steps taken to limit damage. Notify the insurer now, explain what was done and why, and share the engagement letter and invoices.

Does ACS Cyber sell cyber insurance or decide claims?

No. ACS Cyber does not sell insurance, decide coverage or claims, or give legal advice. We contain the threat, investigate and help you recover, coordinate with your insurer and counsel when you authorize it, and work alongside insurer-assigned response firms where your policy permits.

Get help now, or prepare before you need it

If you are dealing with an attack, call your insurer’s hotline and our 24/7 incident line at 1-650-300-7557, or go to Active Incident Support. To put your incident plan, insurer contacts and pre-approved containment in place before anything happens, book a free 30-minute consultation with our security team.

Want a second opinion on your security?

Talk with an ACS Cyber specialist about your environment, your obligations and the next practical step. Dealing with an active incident? Call our incident line at 1-650-300-7557 (after-hours emergency support is available).

Keep reading

More practical guidance

Your privacy choices

We use a small set of tools to understand how this site is used and to follow up on consultation requests. You can turn optional analytics and marketing cookies off for this browser at any time.

We also keep simple counts of scheduler opens, bookings and calls by page and button. When you book, open our booking calendar on calendly.com, or tap our phone number, we also save which pages of this site you read and for how long, with a random browser ID, so our team can follow up well. Turning analytics off here (or sending GPC) stops this. We honor the Global Privacy Control (GPC) signal. Details are in our Privacy Policy.